Joseph Green and Robert Motherby – Hull Merchants and Kant’s Philosophy


An account of Yorkshire’s medieval trade links with the Baltic. They created a lasting network, not only for businesses and trade, but also for cross-cultural cooperation.
The story begins in former German city of Königsberg now called Kaliningrad and is part of the Russian Federation.

This is an intriguing account how Yorkshire’s medieval trade links with the Baltic created a lasting network, not only for businesses, but also for cross-cultural links.

The story begins in former German city of Kőnigsberg now called Kaliningrad in Russia.

The town was granted a charter in 1255 by the Teutonic Order, who conquered a fortified castle of the indigenous Prussians. From 1312 it was the most important military base of the Order. From 1331 – 1394 English knights fought alongside the Order in the Northern Crusades. After the treaty of Krakow in 1525, Kőnigsberg became the capital city of the secular dukedom of Prussia (later called East-Prussia – a province of the Kingdom of Prussia).

       It was an important port and member of the Hanseatic League with a large diverse merchant community, which included English wholesalers as well as Scottish retail traders. There is frequent mention of many English citizens from the East coast including King’s Lynn, Norwich, Hull, York and Beverley among others. Many merchants took their families and settled in towns within the territory governed by the Order. Trading had its origins in the large-scale production of English cloth in the middle of the 14th century. It continued after the Hanseatic League lost its Baltic hegemony to Dutch and English merchants in the 17th and 18th century.

Albertina, the university of Kőnigsberg (now called Kant University) was founded in 1544 by Duke Albert of Brandenburg, who left his position as grandmaster of the Teutonic Order and converted to Lutheranism. As the first Protestant university,

Kant with friends

quickly became a focus for liberal and forward-thinking academics. During the 18th century, its most famous professor was the philosopher Immanuel Kant.

Immanuel Kant (1724 – 1804) was born in Kőnigsberg, son of a harness maker. He never married and rarely left his hometown. As a professor of philosophy, he became one of the central Enlightenment thinkers. His ground-breaking work and writings have made him one of the most influential figures in modern Western philosophy.

       He was sociable and likeable and chose his friends from people, who could increase his knowledge of the world and awareness. He particularly enjoyed the company of wealthy merchants including English and French business people. One of them was the very wealthy grain merchant Jean Claude Toussaint (married Catherine Fraissinet from Kőnigsberg) a Huguenot from Magdeburg.


Kant and his friends

Joseph Green (1727-27th June 1786) was born in Hull and settled in Kőnigsberg. He traded in grains, coal, herring and manufactured goods. He never married.

       Around 1764 Green met Kant and became a close member of his circle of friends and his best friend. Kant often went to Green’s house, which was built in English style in a leafy suburb. Green and Kant shared a deep appreciation of the ideas of David Hume and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. In addition, Green could provide a perspective on the outside world that was helpful to Kant.

       Meeting on a regular basis, Kant discussed his work with him, including every sentence of his most famous work ‘Critique of Pure Reason’. Kant also entrusted Green with his money. As a professor and later director of the university, his salary was rather modest. Green invested Kant’s savings wisely and made him a wealthy man.

       Green’s sense of order and resulting pedantic punctuality inspired one of the friends, Theodor Gottlieb von Hippel to write the comedy: ‘Der Mann nach der Uhr’. (The Pedantic Timekeeper). Green was highly educated and an excellent scholar of the works of David Hume.

       After Green’s death in 1786, Kant was so deeply affected, that he gave up his evening dinners with friends.

Robert Motherby,

A long-time friend of Immanuel Kant, Motherby was born on 23rd Dec. 1736 in Hull. He had four brothers and three sisters. His father George (b. 20th Dec. 1688) married Anne Hotham (died 1748). Robert probably arrived in Kőnigsberg around 1751 when he was 18 years of age. Through a joint contact in Hull, he was recruited as a young man by Joseph Green, initially as an assistant.  Although he spoke little German, he settled easily and became a business partner and eventually took over the firm Green, Motherby & Co. In 1762 he married Charlotte Toussaint. They had 11 children. One of them was William Motherby, who went on to become a doctor and expert in agriculture in Berlin. Kant always joined the family for Sunday lunch and played and joked with the children.


Marriage certificate of Robert Motherby and Charlotte Toussaint from the Huguenot Church, which clearly states, that he is from Hull. (Added by Bill Longbone, Friends of Hull General Cemetery)

Christening certificate of William Motherby, Robert’s first-born son. (Added by Bill Longbone, Friends of Hull General Cemetery)

A postcard with the image of the Calvinist church, where these ceremonies took place. It was destroyed in WWII. The British Air Force carried out two bombing raids in Aug 26th/27th and 29th/30th 1944.

 The town Council named a street in Kőnigsberg, Motherby Strasse. The name was changed by The Soviet government after 1945.

Society of Kant’s Friends (see www.freunde-kants.com)

      Immediately after Kant’s death, his friends began to commemorate his birthday on 22nd April with a meal. In 1844, this annual event led to the formation of the ‘Society of Kant’s Friends’.After each meal, they took it in turns to give a talk.

Traditional has it that cake is eaten for dessert. Whoever finds a bean in their piece, takes the role of ‘Bean King’ (an honoury title) for a year. In 2016 Marianne Motherby became Bean Queen. She and her brother John Motherby organise the Kant meals on the 22nd April, to this day in Kaliningrad.


Eva La Pensée January 2021

Weasel Words – Ausflüchte


New day – new project. Weasel Words by politicians of all nations.

The house on the Wannsee where the ideas for Nazi genocide were distilled into reality. This picture was taken by me at least 10 years ago. Sometimes things germinate slowly.

I have been working on the idea for years without knowing where it was going. Then an editing job took me to the history of Königsberg and its senseless destruction at the end of World War 2.

‘Senseless destruction,’ is a moot point. It depends where you were at the time. Russian soldiers flogging their way westwards, losing thousands of brothers a day, saw the bombing as necessary. The innocent citizens caught in the firestorm as the old town burned had a different point of view.

And then, there are the excuses – Weasel Words I call them, or Ausflüchte in German and I thought of the instances when senseless actions became senseless excuses. Three occasions seemed worth studying.

  1. The postwar excuses for not bringing all the war criminals to justice – very few were tried.
  2. The famines, tolerated by the British, in Madras over a period of 200 years, the last disaster being contemporaneous with the freeing of Belsen Bergen by British troops. The world was stunned by the starvation pictures in the KZ, but managed not to see the horror in India.
  3. The strategic bombing of Germans towns, especially medieval wood-built such as Dresden. But Dresden is the one we know about. The rest have been forgotten.

I also chose to do them in English and German. Here are the first of Weasel Words – Ausflüchte. Mass Murder in two languages.

Part 1. Topography of Terror

The Museum in Berlin, built on the site of the old GESTAPO Headquarters

1.	Winter at the Museum

It’s winter in Berlin.
Snow and iced paths lead past
Arched remains of the
Gestapo Head Quarters.
The Topography of Terror rises
In glass and steel - a museum
About state-sanctioned murder
With free entrance in two languages.
Why? Why now?


2. Das Museum in Winter

Es ist Winter in Berlin.
Mit Schnee und Eis bedeckte Wege führen
An den übrig gebliebenen Gewölben
Des ehemaligen Gestapo Hauptquartiers vorbei.
Die Topographie des Terrors
Ragt aus Stahl und Glas empor.
Ein Museum des staatlich sanktionierten Mordes,
Für kostenlosem Eintritt, zweisprachig.
Warum? Warum jetzt?

Where to, now? I’m trying to find a publisher in Berlin. Watch this space.

I heard the river laugh


It is finished. 16 short prose pieces – or are they poems? I don’t know, but I have received great praise at open mic readings.

Numbers 1 to 5 have been posted here. Now the entire collection is available through Amazon, as a beautiful chapbook or full colour eBook. But if you would like an unlocked pdf for your classroom or reading circle, please drop me a line under contacts and I will be onto it.

An amazing tree that has fought off human activity to survive.

It illustrates my poem in tribute to Rachel Carlson – author of Silent Spring

Screaming trees (5)


Number 5 in my series, ‘I hear the river laugh.’

 Drilling down

Ever narrower now, energy building, 

Sluicing water upwards, roaring over mudflats, 

Through to Goole, swamping the Ouse and Trent, 

Removing ten thousand years 

Of post-glacial civilisation. 

York and Venice cannot be saved, 

By Tidal Barriers. 

Profits rise with the water 

Until drilling down means holding on 

Against the soaring tides 

And strengthening winds. 

And as the storms merge, 

We ask, ‘What now?’

Screaming trees (5)


Drilling down


Ever narrower now, energy building
Sluicing water upwards,
Roaring over mudflats,
Through to Goole,
Swamping the Ouse and Trent,
Removing ten thousand years
Of post-glacial civilisation.
York and Venice cannot be saved,
By Tidal Barriers.
Profits rise with the water
Until drilling down means holding on
Against the soaring tides
And strengthening winds.
And as the storms merge,
We ask, ‘What now ?’

Part 5 of my series, I heard the river laugh.

Screaming trees (4)


Number 4 in my series, I heard the river laugh.

e-book soon available for your Kindle. Today’s picture is of a disused coal-fired power station in Thuringia.

My next poem will be on Tuesday next.

Screaming trees (3)


Number 3 in my series, I heard the river laugh.

Soon available as a chapbook.

Screaming trees (2)


Number 2 in my series on the effects of global warming on the Holderness Plain, where I live.

Please let me know what you think.

My chapbook is nearly ready and free to any environmental group, to use and sell. Just let me know.

Screaming trees (1)


Set of ten poems – I heard the river laugh. Copyright free to an environmental group.

More soon.

Glaciers mop up the heat. What happens when they are done?

Capitalism’s Dirty Tricks


‘Using Bridgewater’s public disclosures, Breakout Point calculated that the Connecticut-based fund has bet against 21 European companies so far this week, in sectors ranging from finance to energy.’

The above quote is from the Daily Express of 17th June 2022.

And of course, there is nothing like a headline such as-

EU issued MAJOR financial warning as biggest hedge fund makes £5.9BN bet against Eurozone

to create a self-fulling prophecy, which was what the Express ran with. The story was also covered by the Telegraph..

Today, Martina Andretta reports on the news site ‘OpenDemocracy.net

‘In the last decade, corporate-funded right-wing think tanks who do not declare their donors have been steadily increasing their connections to the heart of government, securing more than 100 meetings with ministers. More than a dozen of their former staff have joined Boris Johnson’s government as special advisers.

http://www.opendemocracy.net

‘Our investigation revealed that just five influential UK think tanks had received $9m in US ‘dark money’ in the last decade. Funders included US donors who have contributed to climate change denial groups.’

She identifies the donors as climate deniers.

It would appear, that communist philosophers such as Marx and Lenin, although rejected by modern political thinkers, are actually well respected in right-wing circles. Right wing think tanks embrace the need to increase exploitation to maintain profit return.

As capitalism finds it more difficult to turn the profit it expects, it increases the exploitation of the system. For Marx, the system was the working classes, but today the system is more widespread. Climate deniers and oil companies not playing their part in reducing global warming, car manufacturers selling products such as heavy SUVs, giving advances in technology back to the driver in increased performance, instead of reduced pollution during construction and usage etc. are part of the increased exploitation to maintain profit. Of course, working people are least protected from their excesses. The latest scandal, underreported, is the underfunding of the Environment Agency, so they don’t have the capacity to prosecute water companies poisoning our waterways.

And of course, capitalism has invented hedge funds, whose managers are little more than race-course spivs, taking bets on our livelihoods.
Gambling Photo by Denner Nunes on Pexels.com

Marx and Keynes pointed out the need to pay workers enough to consume. Marx said capitalism would never match supply and demand well enough to create security, and would need wars to smooth booms and slumps.

Paying proper wages is old hat, now. Instead we have a credit race, where banks lend to risky clients so that they can keep spending and thereby maintain the growth percentage. When the system readjusts, the savers pay the price by facing decades of low interest rates and zero or negative standard of living shifts.

We are somewhere in the middle of such a crisis, right now.

And there is the next crisis which is an absolute taboo in right-wing circles.

2% growth now, is a much bigger number than 2% fifty years ago. Capitalism has created an unstable expanding economy which is unsustainable, so they dump climate aims. Marx’s crystal ball didn’t flag that one up, but who knew?.

Capitalism sacrifices green objectives Photo by Felix Mittermeier on Pexels.com

Nor did Marx predict that capitalism would create dark money to influence voters in a democracy, so that they vote for their own poverty, but he didn’t live in a social democracy, so how could he know? In the 19th century, such activity wasn’t hidden.

We will see if reckless capitalists are successful in destroying the planet while creating ever harsher working conditions, but their newest tool, Boris Johnson, doesn’t have the subtlety needed to keep fooling all the people, all the time.

For stats and analysis go to Michael Roberts